The French Economy is Sicko
From Cato's Michael Cannon's review of Michael Moore's Sicko:
"You show how greedy insurance companies deny medical care to American patients. But you ignore the fact that power-hungry politicians do the same thing to patients in Canada, Great Britain, France, and Cuba — they just call it "rationing by waiting."
You extol the virtues of France's economic system, which seems to have socialized everything right down to laundry service. But you never tell your audience that taxes in France are 50% higher than in America, or that the French unemployment rate is double the American rate."
1. Like all scarce goods and services, health care has to be rationed somehow - either with prices, or with time, in the form of long waiting lines and times for medical procedures. The problem with "rationing health care by waiting" is that some could die waiting. Even Canada's Supreme Court said, "Patients die as a result of waiting lists for public health care."
2. Despite the rosy picture Moore's paints of life in France and Canada with "free" health care, I am not sure most Americans would want to trade our overall economic conditions for theirs. The chart above shows unemployment rates over the last 10 years in France (average = 9.71%), Canada (average = 7.42%) and the U.S. (average = 4.92%), and I think the message is pretty clear: the French economy is pretty sick.